Chew Toy for a Puppy

Choosing the Perfect Chew Toy for a Puppy: Keep Them Happy, Healthy and Out of Trouble

Bringing a new puppy home is one of life’s greatest joys — but anyone who’s done it knows those sharp little teeth can quickly turn furniture, shoes and even fingers into chew targets. Finding the right chew toy for a puppy isn’t just about fun; it’s about protecting your belongings, encouraging healthy habits, and supporting your puppy’s teething journey.

At Total Pet Supplies, we understand the challenge. Puppies are curious, energetic and driven by instinct to chew. The key is giving them safe, engaging alternatives that satisfy that urge while helping them grow into calm, well-behaved dogs.

Why Puppies Need to Chew

Chewing isn’t a bad habit — it’s a vital part of development. From about 3 to 6 months old, puppies go through a teething phase where baby teeth fall out and adult teeth come in. This process can be uncomfortable, so chewing helps to soothe sore gums and speed up the teething cycle.

But chewing isn’t just for teething relief. It also helps puppies:

  • Explore the world – Just like babies, puppies use their mouths to learn.

  • Develop strong jaws – Regular chewing builds muscle and keeps teeth strong.

  • Prevent boredom – Chewing releases endorphins that help calm energetic pups.

  • Avoid destructive behaviour – When a puppy doesn’t have an approved chew toy, they’ll make one — often from your slippers!

What Makes a Good Chew Toy for a Puppy?

Not all toys are created equal. The best chew toy for a puppy needs to be safe, size-appropriate and durable. Here’s what to look for:

1. Puppy-Safe Materials

Avoid anything that can splinter, tear easily, or be swallowed. Ideal materials include:

  • Soft rubber – Flexible enough for puppy teeth but tough enough to last.

  • Nylon – Great for moderate chewers and helps clean teeth.

  • Rope – Perfect for tug-of-war and light chewing sessions.

  • Natural rubber or latex – Eco-friendly and safe for sensitive mouths.

2. Size and Texture

Choose a chew toy that fits comfortably in your puppy’s mouth — not too big and not small enough to swallow. Textured surfaces are excellent for massaging gums and cleaning teeth as they chew.

3. Engaging Design

Interactive toys, squeakers and treat-dispensing options can keep your puppy busy for hours. Chew toys that challenge them mentally can prevent boredom and anxiety.

Top Types of Puppy Chew Toys

Finding the perfect chew toy for a puppy depends on their personality and chewing strength. Here are some tried-and-tested favourites among Australian dog owners.

Soft Rubber Chew Toys

Soft rubber toys are a teething puppy’s best friend. They’re gentle on the gums and often come in fun shapes like bones or balls. Fill them with peanut butter or soft treats for extra fun.

Rope Toys

Rope toys are fantastic for bonding playtime — they’re safe to chew and great for tug games. They also help with dental hygiene by gently cleaning teeth as your puppy gnaws.

Treat-Dispensing Toys

If your puppy loves a challenge, a treat-dispensing toy will keep them mentally engaged. These toys encourage problem-solving as they roll or chew to release treats, making mealtime more exciting.

Plush Toys

While not the most durable, plush toys are comforting for young puppies, especially during rest or crate time. Always supervise playtime and replace plush toys if they start to tear.

Freezeable Teething Toys

Teething pups love cool relief. Some chew toys can be frozen, which soothes sore gums and reduces inflammation — perfect for hot Australian summers.

Common Mistakes When Buying Chew Toys

Even the most loving owners can make mistakes when choosing a chew toy for a puppy. Avoid these common errors to keep your dog safe and happy.

1. Buying Toys That Are Too Hard

If you can’t make a dent in a toy with your fingernail, it’s too hard for your puppy. Hard toys can break teeth or cause mouth injuries.

2. Ignoring Size Guidelines

A toy that’s too small can be a choking hazard. Always follow the manufacturer’s size recommendations for your puppy’s breed and weight.

3. Overlooking Supervision

No toy is indestructible. Puppies should be supervised during playtime, especially when they’re still learning what’s safe to chew.

4. Not Rotating Toys

Puppies can get bored easily. Keep a few toys aside and rotate them weekly to maintain excitement and novelty.

Training Benefits of Puppy Chew Toys

Using the right chew toy for a puppy can also make training easier. Chewing releases calming hormones that help with impulse control — perfect for learning boundaries.

Here’s how chew toys can support training:

  • Redirecting bad behaviour: When your puppy chews the wrong thing, calmly replace it with a chew toy.

  • Positive reinforcement: Praise your puppy when they chew the right toy.

  • Reducing separation anxiety: Giving them a chew toy when you leave helps them feel secure and reduces stress.

This simple routine teaches your puppy what’s acceptable — saving you countless headaches and chewed-up cords.

How to Keep Chew Toys Clean

A dirty toy can harbour bacteria, so hygiene is key.

1. Wash Regularly

Most rubber and nylon toys can be cleaned with warm soapy water or placed in the top rack of the dishwasher. Rope toys can go through the washing machine.

2. Inspect for Damage

Check toys often for cracks, tears or frayed edges. If any pieces are coming loose, replace the toy immediately to avoid choking hazards.

3. Store Safely

Keep a toy basket in a dry area and rotate toys weekly. This keeps your puppy interested and prevents over-chewing on a single toy.

When to Replace a Puppy’s Chew Toy

Puppies grow fast, and their chewing strength changes just as quickly. Replace their chew toys when:

  • The toy is too small for their mouth.

  • It shows deep bite marks, cracks or fraying.

  • They’ve lost interest in it.

  • You notice it doesn’t challenge them anymore.

As your puppy becomes an adult dog, you can transition to more durable dog chew toys designed for stronger jaws.

Safe Chew Toys at Total Pet Supplies

At Total Pet Supplies, we stock a wide range of chew toys for puppies that tick all the boxes — safe materials, fun designs and proven durability. Whether your pup loves tugging, fetching or just gnawing away after dinner, we’ve got something to suit every breed and age.

Our best-selling puppy chew toys include:

  • Soft rubber bones and rings – Gentle and soothing for teething puppies.

  • Rope toys – Great for dental health and interactive play.

  • Treat-dispensing balls – Keeps pups engaged while rewarding them.

  • Plush comfort toys – Perfect for cuddly, calm downtime.

Explore our full collection at TotalPetSupplies.com.au and find your pup’s next favourite toy — all with fast, affordable Australian shipping.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right chew toy for a puppy is about more than play — it’s an investment in their wellbeing and your peace of mind. Safe, well-chosen chew toys encourage healthy teeth, calm behaviour, and stronger bonds between you and your furry friend.

With high-quality toys from Total Pet Supplies, you can guide your pup through the teething phase with less stress, fewer chewed shoes, and a happier, healthier companion by your side.

Back to blog