The Best Puppy Chew Toys: A Complete Guide for Growing Dogs

• 4 min read
The Best Puppy Chew Toys

Finding the best puppy chew toys isn’t just about keeping your dog entertained — it’s about protecting their health, supporting proper development, and preventing destructive behaviour before it starts. Puppies chew for many reasons: teething discomfort, curiosity, boredom, and learning about the world around them.

At Total Pet Supplies, we specialise in puppy-safe chew toys designed to meet these needs without compromising safety or durability. In this guide, we’ll walk through what makes a great puppy chew toy, the different types available, how to choose the right one for your pup, and how to use chew toys to encourage positive behaviour from day one.

Why Puppies Need Proper Chew Toys

Chewing is a natural and necessary behaviour for puppies — especially during the teething phase, which typically begins around 8 weeks and lasts until 6–7 months of age.

The benefits of puppy chew toys include:

  • Soothing sore gums during teething

  • Supporting healthy jaw and tooth development

  • Preventing furniture, shoes, and household damage

  • Reducing anxiety and boredom

  • Encouraging calm, independent play

Without appropriate chew toys, puppies will create their own chewing outlets, often targeting items that are unsafe or expensive.

What Makes the Best Puppy Chew Toys?

Not all chew toys are created equal — especially for young dogs. The  toys share several critical characteristics that balance durability with safety.

Puppy-Safe Materials

Puppies have developing teeth and jaws, so chew toys must be:

  • Non-toxic

  • Free from sharp edges

  • Flexible enough to avoid tooth damage

  • BPA- and phthalate-free

All puppy chew toys stocked at Total Pet Supplies are selected with these safety standards in mind.

Age-Appropriate Durability

Puppies need toys that are:

  • Softer than adult dog chew toys

  • Tough enough to resist light to moderate chewing

  • Designed specifically for teething mouths

Overly hard toys can damage emerging teeth, while toys that are too soft may be destroyed too quickly.

Types of Puppy Chew Toys (And When to Use Them)

Understanding the different categories of chew toys helps ensure you’re giving your puppy the right option at the right stage.

Soft Rubber Chew Toys

These are ideal for young puppies and early teething.

Benefits:

  • Gentle on gums

  • Easy to grip

  • Often textured to massage gums

Soft rubber toys are excellent starter chew toys and help redirect chewing away from hands and furniture.

Textured Chew Toys for Teething Relief

Textured chew toys include ridges, bumps, and grooves that stimulate gums and provide relief.

Why they work:

  • Increase blood flow to gums

  • Reduce discomfort during teething

  • Encourage longer chewing sessions

Many puppies show a clear preference for textured toys during peak teething months.

Rope and Fabric-Based Chew Toys

These toys are best used under supervision and are ideal for:

  • Light chewing

  • Interactive play

  • Gentle tug games

They’re particularly useful for bonding and teaching bite control.

Treat-Dispensing Chew Toys

These toys combine chewing with mental stimulation.

Key advantages:

  • Encourage calm, focused chewing

  • Reduce boredom and anxiety

  • Extend playtime

When filled with puppy-safe treats, they’re excellent for crate training and solo play.

How to Choose the Best Puppy Chew Toy for Your Dog

Every puppy is different — breed, size, chewing intensity, and temperament all matter.

Consider Your Puppy’s Size

Choose a chew toy that:

  • Cannot be swallowed whole

  • Fits comfortably in your puppy’s mouth

  • Is appropriate for their breed size

A toy that’s too small can be dangerous, while one that’s too large may discourage use.

Match the Toy to Chewing Strength

Some puppies are gentle nibblers, while others are enthusiastic chewers.

  • Light chewers: Softer rubber or fabric toys

  • Moderate chewers: Flexible rubber with reinforced textures

  • Persistent chewers: Thicker rubber designed for longer chewing sessions

Rotating toy types can also prevent boredom.

Watch Your Puppy’s Preferences

Puppies will tell you what they like. If one toy is ignored while another is constantly used, take note and adjust future choices accordingly.

Using Chew Toys to Prevent Destructive Behaviour

Chew toys aren’t just toys — they’re training tools.

Redirecting Unwanted Chewing

When your puppy chews something inappropriate:

  1. Calmly remove the item

  2. Immediately offer a chew toy

  3. Praise when they engage with the toy

Consistency is key.

Creating a Chew Toy Rotation

Keeping 3–5 chew toys in rotation:

  • Maintains novelty

  • Prevents boredom

  • Reduces fixation on household items

Store unused toys out of sight and rotate them every few days.

Safety Tips for Puppy Chew Toys

Even the best toys require supervision and maintenance.

Always Inspect Toys Regularly

Check for:

  • Cracks

  • Loose pieces

  • Excessive wear

Replace damaged toys immediately.

Avoid Household Items as Chew Toys

Items like socks, shoes, or towels teach puppies that human belongings are acceptable to chew, which can create long-term behavioural issues.

When to Upgrade from Puppy to Adult Chew Toys

As your puppy grows and adult teeth fully develop, you may need to transition to more durable chew toys.

Signs it’s time to upgrade:

  • Toys are destroyed quickly

  • Chewing intensity increases

  • Adult teeth are fully visible

Total Pet Supplies offers chew toys suitable for every stage of your dog’s development.

Recommended Puppy Chew Toy Range at Total Pet Supplies

For a curated selection of toys designed for teething, training, and enrichment, explore our full range of
👉 puppy chew toys and dog toys

This internal collection is ideal for finding age-appropriate chew toys that meet Australian pet safety expectations.

Expert Guidance on Puppy Chewing Behaviour

For additional Australian-specific advice on puppy development and chewing behaviour, the RSPCA Australia provides helpful educational resources for new pet owners.
👉  https://www.rspca.org.au

(Used for behavioural education only — product recommendations should always come from trusted retailers like Total Pet Supplies.)

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Best Puppy Chew Toys

Choosing the best puppy chew toys is one of the simplest and most effective ways to support your puppy’s health, comfort, and behaviour. With the right chew toys:

  • Teething becomes easier

  • Destructive habits are reduced

  • Puppies stay engaged and calm

  • Training becomes more effective

At Total Pet Supplies, we focus on safe, durable, puppy-approved chew toys that help set your dog up for a happy, healthy life.

Australia Chew toys Dog Dog Toys Puppy Stuffed Dog Toys Toys